Beyoncé, the iconic singer, and entertainer, when celebrating her 40th birthday; Glamour Magazine honored the occasion by publishing an article ranking her best and worst songs.
However, many fans took to Beyoncé's defense when one of her songs was ranked as the worst one she's put out.
The Beyhive, known for their fierce loyalty to Beyoncé, took to social media to express their displeasure with McDuffie's assessment of "Kitty Kat."
The backlash was so intense that it became a trending topic on Twitter, with fans passionately defending the song's merits.
One Twitter user named Mick declared, "Kitty Kat is literally one of Beyoncé's best songs." Another user, Mel Smith, praised the song's bridge and post-bridge rap, stating, "Kitty Kat is undoubtedly the best Beyoncé record to ever exist."
Let's break it down.
What Song Was Ranked As Beyoncé's Worst?
When the song "Kitty Kat" ranked among the worst in Beyoncé's discography, it ignited a passionate response from Beyhive, the devoted fanbase of the iconic singer Beyoncé. The rankings were put together by Candace McDuffie, a writer for Glamour, who meticulously compiled a list featuring the ten best and ten worst tracks from Beyoncé's solo catalog.
To preface the rankings, McDuffie felt compelled to insert a disclaimer at the beginning of her article, emphasizing that her opinion was that all of Beyoncé's songs were undeniably amazing, stating: "Spoiler: They're all amazing."
Within the list, three tracks emerged as the top favorites: "Formation," "Mood 4 Eva," and "Me, Myself & I." These choices were approved, showcasing the brilliance of Beyoncé's musical prowess.
However, the inclusion of "Kitty Kat" as the second-worst song attracted the most attention and stirred up controversy among fans. The Beyhive expressed their passionate disagreements, defending their beloved artist and challenging the placement of "Kitty Kat" on the undesirable end of the spectrum.
Despite the debate, McDuffie's rankings served as a testament to the diverse opinions that can arise when evaluating the vast and impressive discography of an artist as revered as Beyoncé.
Why Was "Kitty Kat" Ranked the Worst?
"Kitty Kat," produced and co-written by The Neptunes, appears on Beyoncé's sophomore album B'Day.
McDuffie criticized the song's accompanying music video and Beyoncé's attempt to channel a feline alter-ego with her vocals. She described the video as cringeworthy, with Beyoncé wearing a sequined leopard-print bodysuit while riding an oversize black cat.
McDuffie argued that although taking creative risks is commendable, she believed Beyoncé missed the mark with this endeavor.
The Beyhive's Reaction to "Kitty Kat" Being Ranked The Worst
Many fans challenged McDuffie's opinion, with one digital creator named Fonz Franc posting a cartoon image of a girl with an incredulous expression, adding a handgun and bullets on a desk to emphasize their disbelief. Another user named Tierra Harris questioned the age of the Glamour editor.
The article's choice for the worst song on the list was "Beautiful Liar," another track from the B'Day album featuring a duet with Shakira.
McDuffie argued that the song feels cheap and relies too heavily on each artist's sexual desirability rather than vocal capabilities.
Once again, fans took to Twitter to express their disdain, with one user named Donovan criticizing the inclusion of "Kitty Kat" and calling it "bold and dumb."
Another user, Young Padajuan, called out McDuffie's picks in the least-favorite list, mentioning "Sandcastles," "Superpower," and "Beautiful Liar." The user expressed frustration, stating, "I'm starting to understand why the Beyhive used to chase people off the internet."
Despite the mixed reactions, it is important to note that Beyoncé's B'Day album was a huge success, reaching triple-platinum status and becoming her second best-selling album, according to Billboard. It produced several top-charting hits, including "Irreplaceable," "Déjà vu," and "Beautiful Liar."
Ultimately, the debate over Beyoncé's "worst songs" is subjective, and opinions will naturally differ among fans. While some may vehemently disagree with including "Kitty Kat" and "Beautiful Liar" on the worst songs list, others may have their preferences.
One thing is certain: Beyoncé's extensive discography continues to captivate and resonate with her fanbase, solidifying her status as a powerhouse in the music industry.
Beyoncé's music has always been a discussion and debate topic, and including "Kitty Kat" among the alleged worst songs only fueled the fire. However, it's important to remember that music is a highly personal and subjective experience. What one person may perceive as a "worst" song, another may consider a hidden gem.
Beyoncé's ability to continually push creative boundaries and take risks is one of the reasons why she has such a dedicated fanbase. She has consistently challenged conventional norms throughout her career and experimented with different sounds and styles. This willingness to evolve and explore new territories has undoubtedly contributed to her success and influence.
The fact that a song like "Kitty Kat" can generate such passionate responses from fans showcases the power of Beyoncé's artistry. Her ability to connect with her audience deeply emotionally is a testament to her talent and the impact she has had on popular culture.
Ultimately, the controversy surrounding "Kitty Kat" and the other songs on the list is a testament to Beyoncé's artistry and the unwavering support of her fans. While opinions may differ, it's undeniable that Beyoncé has left an indelible mark on the music industry, and her influence will continue to resonate for years to come.
