Sister Wives Season 19 Episode 2 Recap

TLC's long-running polygamy saga Sister Wives' Season 19 debuted last week, with a premiere that was genuinely bananas.

Sister Wives Season 19 premiere was sort of devoted to bringing the audience up to speed in terms of the Brown family's complex disintegration.

Monogamous reality TV romantic entanglements can be difficult for even dedicated fans to follow, much less non-monogamous relationships with layered divorces (or "releases.")

Season 19 of Sister Wives is airing now, but it depicts events from late 2022.

Because Sister Wives has been a TLC staple for so long, its primary stars – Kody, Meri, Janelle, Christine, and Robyn – are somewhat famous as individuals, and developments in their lives sometimes make the news before attendant plot lines play out on TV.

For instance, a day after Sister Wives premiered, Christine sued Kody, seeking child support for their daughter, Truely — incidentally, a move which tied very much into the financial themes of Episode 2.

As such, it's fairly common knowledge that some of the things occurring during Season 19 have been resolved off-screen.

It's also known that Kody has separated from three of his four wives (Christine, Janelle, and Meri), whereas the latter two wives are still disentangling themselves from Kody early in this season.

When we left the Brown family and their rapidly changing dynamics behind last week, Christine was thrilled to be single, Janelle and Meri were limbo, Kody was resigned to monogamy, and Robyn was holding out hope her sister wives would rejoin their plural marriage.

In other words, if Sister Wives' Season 19 premiere answered a broader "what" question, Episode 2 finally got into some of the "whys."

2:00

The Collapse of the Sister Wives Family Runs Deeper Than Kody Brown's Treatment Of His Wives

Kody Brown is largely blamed for the Sister Wives family's split, but other members of the Brown family have also contributed.

Posts

Sister Wives S19 E2 Confirmed So Much Fan Speculation

Sister Wives' second episode followed the standard format of depicting interactions within the Brown family in a loose chronological order, but at the same time, it kept revisiting some core themes — primarily, money and assets.

At the beginning of the episode, Janelle and Maddie take a detour to look at land in Montana, in a scene interspersed with confessionals and cuts to subsequent conversations between Janelle and Christine.

It's pretty clear Janelle is having a hard time explaining her position to Christine, and Christine mentions she "quit claimed" (i.e., relinquished) her portion of the Coyote Pass parcel to make a clean break.

Janelle and Meri's only shared asset is the land, and Christine's ability to get out of Dodge with the quickness seemed to jibe with fan speculation at the end of Season 18 about the "real reason" Kody was so angry with Christine:

"Christine escaped with all the money from the sale of a big asset, her house. Kody made a mistake in taking his name off that property with her, she then grabbed that opportunity and ran.

"That’s why he’s so bitter. She outsmarted him and he’s probably kicking himself for that stupid mistake. Kody is a failed cult leader."

As the scene continued, Janelle explained that Kody seemed to be dodging her questions about what to do with her portion of the Coyote Pass land, and Kody immediately confirmed her suspicions in a separate confessional.

Kody made sure to give a paper thin reason for keeping Janelle in the dark about her equity in the land:

"Janelle asks me about property all the time ... I don’t trust her, I don’t give her information ... I'm tired of disclosing information, and it goes through the gossip mill."

Fair division of property largely defined the episode, with definite recurring themes: Christine, Janelle, and Meri described being cheated out of a share of the assets, and Kody and Robyn blamed them and denied it.

Janelle pondered buying more of the land due to a pending deadline for the loan, and she and Kody's daughter Maddie indicated that Janelle's money had been converted into "Robyn's equity":

That would get you back some of the money you put [into] Robyn’s equity.

At that point, several of the Brown family members' confessionals were cut together, continuing the focus on what seemed like Kody trapping Meri and Janelle in stasis, tying up their only meaningful asset — Coyote Pass.

Janelle and the other ex-wives talked a bit about how money was pooled before the split, and all seemed to agree that Robyn got a bigger piece of the pie ... except for Robyn.

Fans on Reddit's r/TLCsisterwives (and r/SisterWives) have long focused specifically on the costly art displayed in Robyn's house — and once again, that speculation was validated on the show, leading to an excited, cheering comments section:

"JANELLE MENTIONED THE ART"

"Came here for this 😂"

"The way I SCREAMED 💀"

"I legit stood up and cheered"

"She’s been paying more attention than we gave her credit for, Janelle is both the most observant and I think smartest of them… I think that’s what Kody loved the most about her, he could talk to her about business and bounce ideas off her… I’m really happy she’s finally going to live her life for herself …"

In a confessional, Robyn – who constantly claims she wants her sister wives to come back – huffily said the other three were not responsible with their money, adding: "That's all."

There was a classic Kody moment where he complained about wife-on-wife "jealousy," phrased it as if it was the most preposterous accusation in human history, validated it, and then minimized it:

There’s a lot of misguided jealousy ... trash talk ... is some of it true? Some of it probably is, but most of it’s not.

Notably, if even a fraction of what Meri, Christine, and Janelle say is true, it's less "misguided jealousy" and more "warranted frustration that Kody and Robyn relied on an uncommon marital structure to enrich themselves while excluding Kody's other wives."

At the end of Episode 2 of Sister Wives, the show veered to Robyn's claims that her children were treated badly by the other wives' children, and everyone discussed a Christmas gift-related text chain from which some sort of dispute originated.

Kody also seemed to say that he wasn't helping Meri or Janelle break the religious component of their marriages, a "release" from their "covenant," and he tried to suggest that he wanted to leave those marriages but couldn't.

But because it's Kody, he also had to be unnecessarily cruel to them in saying it:

"Christine, Janelle, and Meri all chose to have me leave the home ...

"I wasn’t ever going to leave them, no matter how much I didn’t love them."

But again, because it's Kody, he contradicted himself as the episode ended, whining: "It was my club and I got kicked out of it."

Episode 3 of Sister Wives, "Am I My Brother's Keeper?," airs on September 29 on TLC, and the following day on Max and Discovery+.